Top Best 3 Bakeries in Cape May, NJ

Who can resist the sweet smells and freshly baked goodness produced by local bakers and their ovens? Cape May, NJ, is lucky to feature a historic beach town several great eateries, while housing a few spectacular bakeries, as well. We have chosen the top three bakeries for you to discover while you journey throughout downtown Cape May in search of a delicious treat.

1. Madison’s Bakery

Madisons Bakery Cape May

Located in Cape May, you’ll notice Madison’s Bakery and its storefront, thanks to the cupcakes, cakes and deserts on display. Madison’s Bakery works with local suppliers to source the freshest, most authentic ingredients and use old-fashioned techniques to ensure the highest quality. Their goal is to make your taste buds extremely happy! With the chilly fall days approaching, Madison’s Bakery offer comfortable seating inside their bakery with free Wi-Fi and plenty of outlets for you to get some work down or to enjoy an afternoon catching up with friends!

2. Avalon Coffee Cape May


Felicia’s Cake Factory offers home baked goods created with both passion and family-inspired recipes using the finest and freshest ingredients. This gourmet bakery and coffee shop has 11 different homemade Gourmet Cream Cheeses that pair perfectly with their Artisan Bagels. Our Muffins, Scones, Croissants, Cinnamon Buns, Sticky Buns and not only taste great but also look beautiful. They also specialize in Espresso, Lattes, Cappuccinos, Chai Teas, Frozen coffee drinks and a large selection of Teas.

A storefront that emerged in Cape May in 2005 and has since been pumping out savory snacks while keeping local businesses in mind. From their signature breakfast sandwiches to a delicious Herb Crusted Turkey sandwich, Avalon Coffee can deliver you a delicious meal.  

3. Chez Michel Bakery


A French patisserie in Cape May offering fresh pastries, cakes, baguettes, multigrain breads, croissants, cinnamon buns, sticky buns, custom wedding cakes, and various French items. Michel Gras is a classically trained French pastry chef with 35 years’ experience. His passion for doing only the very best is reflected in his spectacular wedding cakes. He works hard to provide everything a bride and fiancé are looking for that special occasion – friendly staff, finest ingredients, fun experience, and the masterpiece of your dreams that will leave you smiling and impress your guests.

Check Out These Top Bakeries

The next time you find yourself enjoying historic Cape May, be sure to check out either of these bakeries for a sweet, fresh baked snack. Take that baked good to go as you explore everything the area has to offer with cooler days upon us. Be sure to check out the bakery’s link that interests you most to learn more about what treats are available for you to devour.